Students who are having difficulty with subjects that they are trying to understand can benefit tremendously from the assistance of a private tutor in the traditional sense. Tutors are able to assist you in comprehending the material in a manner in which your instructors might not be able to. A tutor will also know which aspects of the topic you need to focus on improving, and they will direct the majority of their attention there so that you can get more out of your sessions.
If you have been thinking about hiring a tutor but don't know where to start looking for one, a good place to start is by asking friends or family members who have previously benefited from tutoring for recommendations. There is also the option of conducting a search online for local listings of tutors in your region.
In this post, we will investigate whether or not students benefit from the traditional form of private tutoring. It will provide an analysis of the benefits and drawbacks of both approaches, as well as a conclusion regarding which approach is superior.
Private tutoring in the traditional sense can take place either one-on-one or with a group of students who share similar requirements. Using this approach, the tutor is paid a predetermined hourly rate for each individual student that they instruct during their sessions.
It is difficult to spend more time on topics that require more attention or review material if it is necessary because there are fixed time limits per session in this type of teaching, which is one of the drawbacks of this type of instruction. Because of this, by the end of the session, the participant may have a less robust understanding of the material because not all concepts were covered in sufficient depth due to the time constraints.
Does Traditional Tutoring Help Students: Statistics and Facts
For a very long time, parents have looked to conventional one-on-one private tutoring as a means of enhancing their children's academic performance and grade point averages at school. Therefore, it's possible that you've also found yourself questioning whether or not the time and money spent on private tutoring is worth it, as well as whether or not it produces the desired results.
Traditional tutoring, as most people understand it, is effective and beneficial to the students who participate in it. The truth, on the other hand, is considerably more nuanced than that. Traditional tutoring is capable of being very beneficial and helpful in many different situations. Despite this, there are some circumstances in which it won't be of any use.
So that you can make an educated decision that is in the best interest of both your child and their future, let's take a look at a few facts and statistics regarding traditional tutoring.
On Average, Traditional Tutoring Does Not Show Significant Results
It's possible that the first item on our list will surprise you. However, the results of several studies carried out in the United States have led researchers to the conclusion that traditional tutoring does not help students in the same way that we might expect it to. There is neither significant growth nor gains as a result of this.
Does this imply that you should completely dismiss the thought of working with a private tutor in the future? No. Even though the results show that private tutoring is ineffective on average, this does not mean that it is ineffective for all students.
According to the findings of research, there are a number of factors which, if taken into consideration, can in fact produce superior results.
A child's life may revolve heavily around the person they choose to hire as a private tutor. Nevertheless, the findings of this research show that you can't just pick any private tutor or the least expensive one you have access to. You run the risk of squandering both your time and your resources if you do not exercise caution when selecting a private tutor or an organisation that offers private tutoring services.
Let's take a look at some additional findings to determine how you can arrive at the most appropriate choice.
Research-Based Tutoring Produces Improved Results
Several different bodies of research have come to the conclusion that tutoring programmes that make use of elements based on research produce better overall results. What exactly does that entail?
The direct method of instruction is by far the most common and widely used approach to education, and it is still used by a significant number of educators today. Following the introduction of a new concept or rule by the instructors, students engage in practise.
This approach, despite its widespread use, is not the one that yields the best results. Students are expected to maintain a state of passivity throughout the activity. Instead, all that is required of them is to listen carefully and imitate.
Lessons that are based on investigation and discovery are proven to produce much more fruitful learning outcomes. This is as a result of students taking an active role in determining the reasons behind and methods behind how something operates. This fosters critical thinking, which not only improves academic performance but also prepares students for the work environment of the future.
Methods that are based on research are not only more interesting and exciting for students, but they can also increase the students' intrinsic motivation. The fact that they call for additional preparation on the part of the instructor or tutor is one of the reasons why not all instructors make use of them.
Allowing Ample Information Processing Time Improves Tutoring Results
Students need to construct a strong foundation in any topic they choose to study before moving on to more advanced material. Should you fail to do so, you may find yourself falling behind in the future.
Students in large classroom settings typically have a variety of approaches to learning as well as varying rates of comprehension. As a consequence of this, they do not process and absorb the information at the same rate. As a consequence of this, some students will complete it in a shorter amount of time, while others will not be able to finish it before moving on to the next topic in the lesson.
According to a number of studies, producing more significant results can be achieved by allowing ample time for the processing and assimilation of information. The amount of time that each student requires will vary. Therefore, in order for this to happen, it is necessary for the tutor to get to know their tutee and their individual learning style as well as their needs.
Positive Student –Tutor Relationship Can Improve Private Tutoring Results
A good rapport between the tutor and the student is essential to the success of private tutoring, as it is one of the most important factors in the process. This indicates that it is important to consider how well your child gets along with their tutor.
According to one piece of research, private tutoring can be beneficial for students, but only if the tutors make an effort to understand the students' home lives and other aspects of their lives. It has been demonstrated that if students feel they can relate to their instructor, they are more likely to succeed academically.
This also indicates that working with the same tutor over a longer period of time is beneficial, which is another factor that contributes to improved results. Keep in mind, however, that this only applies to tutors who assist your child and who have a positive relationship with your child. Tutors who don't do either of these things are not acceptable. If your child is unhappy with the tutor or if you do not observe any signs of improvement, do not be afraid to look for another option.
Private Tutoring Can Boost Self Confidence
Research shows that traditional tutoring can help students boost their self-confidence levels. While this may not help your child get better grades right away, it can be extremely beneficial long term.
A self-confident student is more likely to participate, answer questions, and be less afraid of making mistakes. There are all essential not only for optimal learning but work environment in the future.
Coordinating Tutoring with School Curriculum Improves Results
Studies have shown that tutors who coordinate private tutoring sessions with the curriculum taught at school help students more than teaching unrelated topics.
This doesn’t mean that tutors need to teach exactly what’s been taught at school. Instead, they can provide additional, hands-on practice that helps reinforce school material and make it more applicable and relatable.
Tutors Who Continuously Develop Perform Better
Learning is not something that should stop for anyone, not just students. The findings of numerous studies demonstrate that students benefit greatly from working with tutors who are committed to lifelong education and improvement.
This is significant because both the subjects that are taught and education as a whole are constantly undergoing change. Because of this, private tutors are better equipped to keep abreast of the most effective teaching methods as well as developments in their respective industries.
Frequent Private Tutoring Sessions Result in Better Gains
The availability of a private tutor should be a significant factor that you take into consideration when deciding whether or not to hire them. Even if you find and hire the very best tutor in the world, your results could suffer if they are only available once every two weeks.
According to the findings of a study, traditional tutoring sessions should be held more frequently, even if they are to be kept to a shorter duration. In addition to that, the research looked at the effectiveness of tutoring sessions of varying lengths (ranging from 10 to 60 minutes), and it found that longer sessions did not necessarily produce better outcomes. It was the regularity of their occurrence that was of primary importance.
Cheap Tutoring Alternatives Do Not Yield Effective Results
These days, information on just about anything can be found on the internet, and traditional online tutoring options from other parts of the world are no exception. If you have already thought about those options, you should probably stop looking any further.
A study that was carried out in the UK found that receiving tutoring over the internet from reasonably priced teachers in India and Sri Lanka resulted in little to no improvement.
Traditional Tutoring Can Help Students, But
Traditional tutoring is something that a lot of parents automatically assume will be beneficial for their children, but this isn't always the case. Because of this, it is essential to choose a tutor carefully; otherwise, you run the risk of squandering both your time and your money.
Be sure to pick a skilled and experienced professional who is always working to improve themselves, who gets along well with your child, who considers your child's unique requirements, who provides imaginative hands-on practise, and who is available for frequent private tutoring sessions.
Online vs. Traditional Tutoring: Which Is Best?
It is of the utmost importance to see to it that your child receives a good education. It has the potential to determine their knowledge and skills, as well as the grades they receive, the colleges they are qualified to attend, and the jobs they will have in the future. Therefore, many parents choose to invest in private tutoring for their children in order to improve their academic performance at school. However, they are faced with the challenge of choosing between traditional and online tutoring.
Along with the development of new technologies come new opportunities for private tutoring; today, these opportunities include both traditional and online learning environments. It shouldn't come as a surprise because getting an education online is becoming more and more common.
Massive online platforms such as Udemy and Coursera offer professional training at prices that are affordable, allowing students to complete their studies from the convenience of their own homes. Even degrees from four-year universities can be earned through study at an online university.
To what extent, however, is online tutoring successful? Is it an improvement over the more common in-person tutoring sessions? Or does more conventional tutoring still produce more fruitful results?
Let's find out by comparing traditional tutoring to tutoring done over the internet.
What Is Online Tutoring?
Online tutoring is a virtual teaching practice that uses the Internet, computer, tablet, and other gadgets. The tutor and the student meet online rather than in person. They may use tools such as whiteboards, e-mails, video, and audio to communicate.
Online Tutoring Benefits
Convenience and Flexibility
Traditional tutoring does not compare to the flexibility and convenience that can be found with online tutoring. As long as your child has access to the Internet, there is no need for them to commute to school, and they can complete their work from just about any location. Your child does not need to miss a session of tutoring even if you are going to be gone for an extended period of time.
In addition, there is a wider variety of tutors and courses available through online tutoring. Therefore, you have the opportunity to gain access to tutors who are both qualified and experienced as well as a variety of course options that may not be offered in your location.
Since online tutoring platforms hire distance teachers, they do not need to cover overhead costs. Thus, in many cases, you can expect lower fees. Though it will not always be the case. There are popular online tutoring programs that can cost more than traditional tutoring where you live.
Online Tutoring Weaknesses
May Not Be Suitable for Hands-On Skills
While it’s not impossible to teach hands-on skills, it will require more interactive tools and creativity to do so in online tutoring. Younger children who learn best through imitating others or extraverted children may prefer traditional tutoring for hands-on skills.
More Susceptibility to Distractions
The tutor has a greater degree of control over the situation when it comes to traditional tutoring. They have the ability to verify who and what is present in the room. Because of this, they are able to get rid of potential distractions.
When it comes to online tutoring, things are handled differently because the instructor is not physically present in the classroom. The use of mobile phones, access to the Internet, siblings, or other people living in the house are all common sources of distraction. If your child does not have the motivation to study or has not developed healthy study habits, he or she may put off completing assignments until the last minute, which can become a problem.
What Is Traditional Tutoring
Traditional tutoring is a teaching practice when the tutor and the student meet in person. Depending on the teacher’s preferred teaching approaches and methods, they can use traditional teaching resources such as books and handouts as well as more modern ones.
Traditional Tutoring Benefits
People are social creatures, and face-to-face interactions are unmatched by any other form of communication. Intrinsic motivation can be increased, and both performance and results can improve, if a student has a positive relationship with their private tutor.
Communication in person can be very useful when it comes to hands-on skills, because a teacher is able to assist and provide more individualised assistance in these situations.
Young students who thrive on interpersonal communication, learn best by emulating adults, and have not yet developed the ability to work effectively on their own independently will also benefit from it. Children who are more extroverted and who are naturally predisposed to interact with other people might also find that in-person tutoring is more beneficial.
In addition, if you decide to have your child attend tutoring or study centres that provide assistance with homework in a manner comparable to that which we do, then your child will have the opportunity to socialise with other children. As a result, they have the opportunity to form friendships with other children who share their values, as well as their academic interests and ambitions.
According to a number of studies, children have a greater capacity for learning and improved academic performance when they are able to personally relate to their tutors and form positive relationships with them. Curiously, however, other studies have examined the topic and come to the conclusion that less expensive online tutoring options available from countries such as Pakistan and India are ineffective.
Ability to Respond to Emotions and Body Language
Teachers with years of experience typically have an understanding of psychology and are able to comprehend the feelings, facial expressions, and body language of their students and respond appropriately. After that, knowledgeable tutors will be able to respond appropriately.
A child's tendency to be reserved is something that a private tutor can pick up on and adjust their method of instruction to accommodate. Additionally, it is much simpler to recognise when a student is becoming bored, uninterested, or distracted and to take appropriate action.
When it comes to online tutoring, this can be challenging or even impossible, especially if it requires a child to follow a programme and only refer to a tutor for guidance, clarifications, and evaluation of their progress.
It is also essential to keep in mind that not all private tutors will have the ability, the experience, or the willingness to read a child's emotions and body language and adapt their teaching style to meet the child's specific requirements. This is something that you should keep in mind. Therefore, it is absolutely necessary to be selective when selecting a private tutor.
Traditional Tutoring Weaknesses
One of the parties needs to make the trip in order for the more traditional form of tutoring to take place in person. If that turns out to be the tutor, then you should plan on spending more money to cover their travel expenses. Because they would need to transport the teaching aids and materials to your home, this can also restrict the quantity of them and the types of materials that can be used by a tutor.
If this is the child who commutes, their parent or another adult would need to drive them or walk them to the location where the tutoring takes place. This can be inconvenient, impractical, and stressful, and it also limits the amount of time that can be spent tutoring and the options that are available to the tutor.
One of the primary reasons why many people choose not to go for private tutoring is its costs. When it comes to traditional in-person tutoring, it is usually more expensive than some other online options.
This is due to the fact that it requires covering different expenses such as transportation if you hire a tutor who comes to your home. Tutors who come to students' homes are more expensive. If you attend a learning centre, the owners of the centre need to be able to cover their overhead costs, which can include the cost of utilities, the purchase of new materials, and other costs.
Online Vs. Traditional Tutoring: Which Should You Choose
None of the possibilities is perfect in every way, and each one comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Therefore, it is extremely important to evaluate the requirements and preferences of your child.
It is important to refrain from making all of your child's decisions for them. Your child may be more open to the different possibilities after you have talked to them about them. This will also assist you in selecting the alternative that caters the most closely to their requirements.
It can also be beneficial to try online and traditional tutoring so that your child can experience both and make an informed choice based on what works best for them.
It is important to keep in mind that there will be online and traditional tutoring providers of great quality as well as low quality, the latter of which can cause you to waste your money and not deliver the results you desire. Therefore, it is necessary to review and evaluate the various options that are available.
Why Do Parents Pay For Tutoring?
The tutoring market offers parents many options. Services range from help with homework, to test and examination coaching and instruction in the reading and writing content of the Australian Curriculum: English.
The vast majority of the parents that we asked about their children's academic struggles mentioned that they had their children work with a private tutor.
In some cases, the issue was caused by a specific deficiency in knowledge or abilities. For instance, one parent was opposed to their child receiving tutoring; however, after seeing a slight decline in their child's English grades:
"We were at a loss to explain why or how he went from getting perfect scores to receiving a grade of only B in English. And so, we just talked to some other parents, and they said that having a tutor was really beneficial for their children's academic performance. Therefore, we travelled there, and the primary topic of discussion was his lack of confidence in his writing."
This was a one-time only session of tutoring.
The second-biggest group of parents told us they used tutoring to support their children’s suspected or diagnosed learning difficulties. These included dyslexia (inability to read accurately), dysgraphia (inability to write coherently), autism and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
One of these parents told us the school couldn’t give enough personalised attention to her child:
"Because the kids are struggling and the curriculum moves so much, and there’s only one teacher to how many kids per class that can’t always spend the time on that one child."
Another took her child to a private tutor during school time to support diagnosed learning difficulties. While this mother felt the tutoring was helpful, the cost became prohibitive. She told us:
"It was something that I had to pay for out of my own personal funds. It was too much, and the amount of money involved is another reason I stopped doing it."
The last and smallest group of parents that we spoke to were the ones who used tutoring as one of the many enrichment activities that they used for their children. There were only three of them in this group.
Two of these parents had assisted their children in preparing for entrance exams or scholarships offered by more prestigious schools. According to what one of the parents shared with us, "we had ten lessons on testing."